When HR Is Also Recruitment: The Hidden Cost of Wearing Too Many Hats
In a safari lodge, private island or remote resort, job descriptions have a habit of becoming rather elastic.
The People & Culture Manager may also be responsible for HR. HR may be responsible for recruitment. And somewhere between contracts, payroll, staff welfare, performance conversations, onboarding, training and the inevitable drama of running a property far from anywhere, someone is also expected to find the next General Manager, Executive Chef or Head of Engineering.
It can work.
Until the hire really matters.
Recruitment is not simply another HR task
There is an understandable tendency to bundle recruitment, HR and People Operations together.
They all involve people, after all.
But they require very different work.
HR manages the framework around employees: contracts, policies, compliance, remuneration and employee relations.
People Operations concentrates on the employee experience: culture, engagement, development, wellbeing and retention.
Recruitment has a different objective altogether: finding the right person who is not yet part of your organisation.
And doing that properly takes time.
A great deal of it.
The best candidate may never apply
Advertising a vacancy is relatively easy.
Executive search is not.
For many of the senior and specialist positions we handle, the person a property really wants may be happily employed elsewhere. They are not necessarily browsing job boards or polishing their CV over breakfast.
They have to be found.
That means understanding the property and the role before the search begins. It means mapping the market, identifying people with the right experience, approaching them discreetly, having real conversations, assessing motivation and suitability, interviewing, following up and keeping them engaged throughout the process.
And in remote hospitality, experience on paper is only part of the equation.
Someone can be an exceptional hotelier and entirely wrong for a lodge three hours from the nearest town.
A brilliant resort executive may discover that island life feels rather less romantic after six months of limited privacy, complicated logistics and the same faces at breakfast, lunch, dinner and the staff bar.
Finding somebody who can do the job is only the beginning.
We need to find somebody who understands where they are going, genuinely wants that life and is likely to stay.
Meanwhile, HR still has a property to run
This is where wearing all those hats begins to have consequences.
Every hour spent searching LinkedIn, reviewing applications, arranging interviews and chasing candidates is an hour your HR or People & Culture team is not spending on the people already employed by the business.
And recruitment rarely arrives conveniently during a quiet week.
A senior resignation lands. A pre-opening deadline moves closer. High season is approaching. A candidate withdraws.
The search becomes another priority on an already crowded desk.
Inevitably, something receives less attention.
Sometimes that is the search.
Sometimes it is the existing team.
Neither is particularly desirable.
Where Crawford & Carruthers fits
We do not replace your HR or People & Culture team.
We become the specialist recruitment arm alongside them.
Crawford & Carruthers Inc. is an executive search firm working exclusively in luxury hospitality, with particular experience across safari lodges, remote resorts, private estates and islands.
We understand that a vacancy is rarely just a list of responsibilities.
Before we search, we need to understand the property itself. Its location. Its culture. Its ownership and management structure. The team. The living arrangements. The operational realities. The challenges that tend not to make it into a job description.
Then we go to market.
Not simply to the people who happen to be looking for work, but to the people we believe should be part of the conversation.
That distinction matters.
What executive search really involves
A good search involves considerably more than producing a shortlist.
There are conversations before the candidate ever agrees to be considered. Questions about partners and families. Remuneration. Rotation. Schooling. Visas. Accommodation. Career trajectory. Why they would leave a good position for this one.
There are expectations to manage on both sides.
There are candidates who look perfect on paper and unravel during a proper conversation.
And occasionally there is the candidate whose CV does not immediately suggest the obvious choice, but whose experience, temperament and understanding of remote hospitality make them precisely the person worth meeting.
Those discoveries require time.
They also require knowing what to look for.
Your people team should be able to look after your people
There is nothing wrong with an HR Director, People & Culture Manager or General Manager recruiting internally. Many do it extremely well.
The question is whether recruitment is the best use of their time when the search is senior, specialist, difficult or geographically challenging.
When you partner with Crawford & Carruthers, you are not merely outsourcing an advert and a pile of CVs.
You are giving the search its own team.
A team whose job is to go into the market, represent your property well, find people you may never have reached through advertising alone, assess whether the opportunity genuinely fits their lives and careers, and bring you a considered shortlist.
Your HR and People Operations teams can then concentrate on something equally important:
Looking after the good people you already have.
And we shall go and find the next one.



Comments